a) What was your impression of Singapore history and
cultural heritage before going on the trail?
b) How has your experience of the trail changed your
perception of Singapore history and her cultural heritage?
c) Share
some insights (if any) about Singapore's past and the way it is represented
(symbolically and physically) that you have gained from the trail.
Having
left secondary school for a long time, I left my knowledge on Singapore's
History with my History teacher. So, embarking on this journey brings back some
vague memory about the Battle.
The
first thing that strikes me was the difficulty we encountered in locating the
markers. In difficulty, I am referring to the discovery of the exact spot of
the markers at the sites, and their accessibility. Before starting our journey
to visit the markers, my group members and I “Googled” for the markers so as to
ensure that they were present and where they were situated at the corresponding
sites. However, I was wrong. We arrived at the site, with the aim in mind, yet we
missed it. We had 5 pairs of eyes looking for it, yet we missed it. We combed
the area again, looking more meticulously, then, we found it. Just from this
incident, it made me realise that even though, there are markers around, one
would miss it even if it were there. If no one notices the marker, no one
actually take the time to appreciate and understand the importance of those
markers - the commemoration of those who actually laid down their lives for our
country.
There
are some markers that we could not even find at the sites despite having the proper
addresses. One example is the Woodlands Causeway marker. It is located along
the stretch of road called Woodlands Waterfront. We had searched for it on one
end of the road but it was located on the other end. This leads me to my next
concern, the inaccessibility of these sites. Referring to the Woodlands
Causeway marker, it is hard to imagine being on foot from one end of the road
to the other to search for the marker. I cannot imagine myself doing it without
having my own personal vehicle. Furthermore, there is no public transport that
we saw passing through that stretch of road.
Another example that I would like to bring to attention is the Sarimbun
site. There are public buses that led to the main road. However, the marker
that is was located deep inside a side road. Even though, we went in a car, the
road condition is bad. My concern was if these markers are so hard to reach, how
can we expect schools and families to take a trip down to teach the young about
our local history? If this is so, teaching our history will mostly remain at
home and in the schools. This will make it even harder to bring history to life
for the children.
Some of
the markers were not well taken care of, for example, the marker located at
Woodlands Causeway. Since this marker marks an important part of
Singapore’s history during the World War 2 Battle, I question the intention of
putting up the markers. Is the marker placed there just for the sake of marking
something or it is meant to truly remember the lives of those who tried their best,
and even laying down their lives to protect the nation? Does this marker mean nothing to the people
of Singapore?
Having
gone through the journey, I used to believe that the Government had done more
than enough to ensure that as a nation we honor the lives of our war heroes and
remember war events, especially, in textbooks and in museums. I am wrong. The
textbooks talk about the dominant narratives and the markers that are found
mimic those. The other narratives, such as the Australian armies and Indian
Army who played a part in defending Singapore, were missing or became just a
little foot note. In Singapore, where
many narratives are difficult to attain, many of the defenders of Singapore who
are not “visible” are left out. But, we owe each and every one of the defenders
a huge thank you for helping us to defend Singapore despite not being a
Singaporean. This is something that we can do to increase our awareness on our
history – the inclusion of multiple perspectives of every community so that we
can have a “well – rounded” standard narrative.
No comments:
Post a Comment